|

The
Institute for Constitutional Studies sponsors or co-sponsors a variety
of events during the academic year. Here is a partial list of upcoming
and recent events.
Upcoming Events
April 11, Noon
GWU Law School Works in Progress
Clearing the Smoke from Philip Morris v.Williams: The Past, Present, and Future of Punitive Damages
Professor Thomas B. Colby (GWU Law School)
Location: Faculty Conference Center, the George Washington University Law School. 2000 H St. NW, Washington, D.C. Lunch will be served. Please RSVP (icsgw@law.gwu.edu) if you would like to attend.
Summer 2008
June 8-14

Ninth Annual Residential Summer Research Seminar, June 8-14, 2008
"The Influence of Religion on Constitutional Thought"
Judge Michael McConnell (Tenth Circuit United States Court of Appeals) and Professor Mark Noll (University of Notre Dame)
Description: Religious thinking has influenced many of the most fundamental features of American constitutional thought. This seminar will explore some of those developments, with focused discussion of selected readings in the morning sessions and paper presentations in the afternoon. Among the topics that may be considered are: (1) Puritan and Reformed Protestant contributions to constitutionalism, republicanism, and revolution; (2) the colonial Great Awakening (Jonathan Edwards) and ideals of society; (3) William Penn and Quaker ideas of political order; (4) Anglicanism, constitutional monarchy, and Loyalist protest; (5) Presbyterian ecclesiology (e.g., John Witherspoon) and ideas of federalism and representation; (6) Baptist theology (including the rejection of infant baptism, e.g., Isaac Backus) and rising individualism and rejection of religious establishment; (7) Masonic ideas (and opposition to them) in the formation of early republican ideology; (8) varying religious appropriations of the Enlightenment; (9) the Second Great Awakening and the rise of voluntarism and civil society; (10) the religious roots of abolitionism and proslavery thought; (11) Lincoln’s theology; (12) women as leaders in church and state; and (13) the 19th-century Roman Catholic critique (e.g., Orestes Brownson) of liberalism. Participants are not limited to these topics, but may prepare and present papers ranging across the modern history of constitutional democracy, based on any significant connection between religious and constitutional thought, broadly construed. For more information follow this link.
July 6-11

Second Annual Regional Workshop for College Teachers: "The Constitutional Convention"
"The Constitutional Convention," our second annual interdisciplinary workshop for college instructors, will take place in Atlanta, Georgia, from July 6 to 11, and will be offered in association with Emory University and the Georgia Humanities Council. Professor Sally Hadden of Florida State University will lead the workshop, along with guest instructors.
This annual workshop is designed for college-level instructors who now teach or
plan to teach undergraduate courses in constitutional studies,
including constitutional history, constitutional law, and related
subjects. All college-level instructors are welcome to apply, including
adjuncts and part-time faculty members, from any academic discipline
associated with constitutional studies (history, political science,
law, anthropology, sociology, literary criticism, etc.). Preference will be given, however,
to applicants from the Southeast region of the
United States and those who teach at liberal arts colleges.
Participants will receive a $500 stipend and some travel expenses and
will be provided with dormitory housing during the workshop. The application deadline is April 11, 2008. For more details click here.
Past Events
Winter 2008
January 5, 2008
A Joint Program of the AALS Executive Committee and Institute for Constitutional Studies at the American Association of Law Schools Annual Conference:
"WHO IS FEDERALISM FOR: LIBERALS, CONSERVATIVES, EVERYONE, OR POLITICAL LOSERS?"
Saturday, January 5, 8:30 a.m., Mercury Ballroom, Third Floor, Hilton New York
Moderator: Neil Kinkopf, Georgia State University, College of Law
Participants: Randy E, Barnett, Georgetown University Law Center
Mark A. Graber, University of Maryland School of Law
Lisa Miller, Rutgers University, Political Science Department
Robert A. Schapiro, Emory University School of Law
Ernest Young, University of Texas
Description: Constitutional Lawyers have recently been considering the value of federalism. Some political liberals now insist on the “local option” for matters as diverse as gay marriage and anti-terrorism policy. Some political conservatives insist that the above policies must be nationalized and maintain that the president, by signing a treaty, may alter state criminal processes. Political scientists have joined the debate. Recent work questions inherited wisdom which proclaims that national politics is more inclusive than local politics. For more details, please visit the conference website.
January 24, 2008 at the National Press Club in Washington, D.C.
"What You Don't Know Can Hurt You: Congress, the Courts, and the State Secrets Privilege"
Sponsored by The Constitution Project
For more information please visit The Constitution Project website at http://www.constitutionproject.org/index.cfm
March 18, Noon
GWU Law School Works in Progress
Family, the Law, and the Constitution(s)
Professor Katherine Baker (Chicago-Kent College of Law)
Location: Faculty Conference Center, the George Washington University Law School. 2000 H St. NW, Washington, D.C. Lunch will be served. Please RSVP (icsgw@law.gwu.edu) if you would like to attend.
March 18, 4 pm
Author Meets Critics
The Day Freedom Died:
The Colfax Massacre, the Supreme Court, and the Betrayal of Reconstruction

A discussion of the new book by Charles Lane of the Washington Post.
Parnelists: Michael Les Benedict, The Ohio State University
Robert M. Goldman, Virginia Union University
Mark Graber, University of Maryland School of Law
Location: Faculty Conference Center, the George Washington University Law School. 2000 H St. NW, Washington, D.C. This event is open to the public. No reservations required. Refreshments will be served.
March 27, Noon
GWU Law School Works in Progress
Dynamic Incorporation of Foreign Law
Professor Michael Dorf (Columbia Law School)
Location: Faculty Conference Center, the George Washington University Law School. 2000 H St. NW, Washington, D.C. Lunch will be served. Please RSVP (icsgw@law.gwu.edu) if you would like to attend.
March 28, 7pm
Our Undemocratic Constitution?
The Institute for Constitutional Studies and the GWU Honors Program present a panel discussion of Sanford Levinson's book, Our Undemocratic Constitution: Where the Constitutuion Goes Wrong (and How We the People Can Correct It)
Friday, March 28, 7:00 pm
The Elliott School of International Affairs
1957 E St. NW, Room 113
Participants: Randy E, Barnett, Georgetown University Law Center
Nathan Brown, George Washington University
Sanford Levinson, University of Texas at Austin
Jamin Raskin, American University Washington College of Law
This event is open to the public. To see the event announcement click here.
March-April 2008
SPECIAL SEMINAR FOR SPRING 2008:

The People and the Judges:
Constitutional Politics and Judicial Review in American History, Monday evenings, March 3, 10, 17, 24, 31, and April 7, 2008.
Michael Les Benedict (The Ohio State University)
Graduate Research Seminar: Most Americans think of the Supreme Court as the final interpreter of the U.S. Constitution, and for the past fifty years the Court has certainly claimed that role. But historians and political scientists have always argued that Court decisions reflect the surrounding historical and political context. Now many legal analysts are exploring how to incorporate this historical reality into jurisprudence. What has been the role of the people themselves in developing constitutional rules? To what degree are constitutional issues legal and to what degree political? What is the relationship between constitutional politics and constitutional law? We will read and critique works that draw conclusions about these questions based on American constitutional history. For more details click here.
Fall 2007
Monday, November 1, 4 p.m.
THE LIMITS OF SOVEREIGNTY: PROPERTY CONFISCATION IN THE UNION AND CONFEDERACY DURING THE CIVIL WAR
Daniel Hamilton (Chicago-Kent College of Law)

George Washington University Law School alumnus Daniel Hamilton, who teaches at Chicago-Kent College of Law, was our featured speaker on Monday, November 12. The meeting took place at 4 p.m. in the Faculty Conference Center at the GW Law School. Professor Hamilton discussed his recent book, The Limits of Sovereignty: Property Confiscation in the Union and the Confederacy During the Civil War.
October 1-November 5 (Mondays at 6 p.m.)
THE PRESIDENCY AND THE SUPREME COURT IN THE AGE OF FRANKLIN D. ROOSEVELT
William E. Leuchtenburg (University of North Carolina)
Distinguished historian William Leuchtenburg led a six-week graduate seminar on the conflict between Franklin D. Roosevelt and the Supreme Court in the 1930's. Professor Leuchtenburg led students through a variety of pertinent constitutional issues, including the expansion of the presidency under FDR, the seminal Supreme Court decisions of 1934-37, the "Court-packing" struggle, and the "Constitutional Revolution" of the 1930s.
Thursday, November 1, 2 p.m.
TO KEEP AND BEAR ARMS: ARMED POLITICAL POWER IN VIRGINIA, 1648-1791
Dr. Christian Vieweg
Dr. Christian Vieweg presented his research on military policy in colonial and revolutionary Virginia. His work examines the ideological and empirical origins of the Second Amendment to the United States Constitution.
Friday, October 19
THE 2007 NATIONAL CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION
The Center for Politics, University of Virginia
ICS participated in UVA's annual constitutional convention, held at the Andrew W.Mellon Auditorium in Washington, D.C. The convention's theme was "A Call to Reform." Prominent scholars, journalists, and politicians participated in the event. Among them were Geraldine Ferraro, Bob Dole, Eleanor Holmes Norton, Bob Schieffer, and Sarah Weddington. More information is available on the center's website, http://www.centerforpolitics.org/.
Summer 2007
Friday, August 31, 2007
Whither Constitutional History: An Intergenerational and Interdisciplinary Conversation
A roundtable discussion at the annual meeting of the American Political Science Association in Chicago.
Panelists include:
Risa Goluboff, University of Virginia
Kathleen Sullivan, Ohio University
Jed Shugerman, Harvard Law School
Leslie Goldstein, University of Delaware
June 11 to 17
Summer Research Seminar: This year the Institute hosted its eighth annual interdisciplinary
summer research seminar. The topic for 2007 was "Constitutionalism" and
the seminar was led by Aviam Soifer (dean of the University of Hawai'i law school) and Mary Sarah Bilder (Boston College). The seminar was open to advanced graduate students and
junior faculty members. Participants received free lodging at George
Washington University, a travel allowance, and a modest per diem to
cover food and additional expenses. Lodging was also provided from
June 6 for participants who want to conduct additional research in the
DC area. For more details click here.
July 8 to 14
Regional Workshop for College Teachers: "New Approaches to Teaching the Constitution," an
interdisciplinary workshop on the Constitution for college instructors.
The workshop was held in Albany, New York, from July 8 to 14, and
was offered in association with the University at Albany (SUNY).
The workshop was led by Sandra F. VanBurkleo of Wayne State University, with guest instructors from several academic disciplines (including Richard Hamm of the University at Albany, Paul Finkelman of Albany Law School, and Stephen Schechter of Russell Sage College).
This annual workshop is designed for college-level instructors who now teach or
plan to teach undergraduate courses in constitutional studies,
including constitutional history, constitutional law, and related
subjects. All college-level instructors are welcome to apply, including
adjuncts and part-time faculty members, from any academic discipline
associated with constitutional studies (history, political science,
law, anthropology, sociology, literary criticism, etc.). However,
preference will be given to applicants from the Northeast region of the
United States and those who teach at liberal arts colleges.
Participants will receive a $500 stipend and some travel expenses and
will be provided with dormitory housing during the workshop. The application deadline was April 13. For more details click here.
April 2007
Thursday,
April 5, noon
Meet the Author: Professor Gerard N. Magliocca
(Indiana University School of Law) discusses his new book on a critical
period of American history, Andrew
Jackson and the Constitution: The Rise and Fall of Generational Regimes
(University Press of Kansas).
According
to the publisher, "Magliocca reinterprets the legal landmarks of the
Jacksonian era to demonstrate how the meaning of the Constitution
evolves in a cyclical and predictable fashion. ... Offering intriguing
parallels between Jackson and George W. Bush regarding the scope of
executive power, Magliocca has produced a rich synthesis of history,
political science, and law that revives our understanding of an entire
era and its controversies, while providing a model of constitutional
law applicable to any period." "This
is a truly
distinguished contribution to our constitutional understanding,
combining theory and history in an exemplary fashion. If you are going
to read one book about our Constitution this year, read Magliocca's."—
Bruce Ackerman (Yale
Law School).
Location: Jacob Burns Moot Court Room
(ground floor of Burns Hall), George Washington University Law
School, 12:00-1:30 pm. The
main
entrance to the
law school is at 20th and H Streets, NW.
Monday,
April 9, noon
Colloquium:
Professor John Fabian Witt of
Columbia University will present a chapter from his forthcoming book, Patriots and Cosmopolitans:
Hidden Histories of American Law. The chapter deals with
the rise of American tort law after WWII, especially how the modern
plaintiffs' bar re-invested the courts with
regulatory power in the decades after the New Deal, and the
significance of American constitutional framework in
explaining American public policy. The chapter will be precirculated,
so please let us know if you would like a
copy.
Location: The Faculty Conference Center at
the George Washington University Law
School (on the 5th floor of the Burns Law Library), at noon on Monday,
April 9. The main entrance to the law school is at 20th and
H
Streets, NW. Lunch will be provided, so please RSVP to icsgw@law.gwu.edu
in advance.
This
colloquium is co-sponsored by the George Washington University Law
School works-in-progress
committee.

The
signing of the Constitution.
Recent
Events
Winter
2006 Spring 2006
Summer 2006
Fall
2006 Winter/Spring
2007
January
2006
Thursday, January 5, 4:00-5:45
Panel:
"Golden
Age, Normal Judicial Politics, or Popular Constitutionalism:
Constitutional Law Before the Civil War"
This
panel
explores revisionist scholarship on antebellum constitutional politics.
Traditional wisdom, best articulated by Charles Warren and Robert
McCloskey, regards this era as a golden age, marked by a sharp
separation
between law and politics. The participants on this panel disagree.
American politics was saturated with constitutional concerns. The
primary motor driving American constitutional development before the
Civil War
was politics out of doors, exhibited for example in popular responses
to
the Alien and Sedition Acts and the use of militia as a form of
constitutional
protest. American constitutional law was saturated with politics. Court
appointments were made with political ends in mind, most justices had
previously been prominent politicians, and such constitutional
struggles as Cherokee
removal can only be understood at the intersection of law and politics.
Panelists: Maeva
Marcus, Director, Institute for Constitutional Studies
(moderator); Saul
Cornell, Professor of History, Ohio State University; Robert J.
Cottrol, The George Washington University Law School; Mark A.
Graber, Professor of Government, University of Maryland
and Professor of
Law, University of Maryland School of Law; Ariela J.
Gross, University of Southern California Gould School of
Law; and Gerard
Nicholas Magliocca, Jr., Indiana University School of Law,
Indianapolis.
Location:
Annual
meeting of the Association
of American Law Schools (Marriot
Wardman Park
hotel,
Washington, DC); conference registration is required
to attend this
session.
This panel
is a joint program of the Institute for Constitutional Studies and the
Executive Committee of the Association of American Law Schools.
February 2006
Friday,
February 10, noon
Colloquium:
Professor Victoria Nourse of the University of Wisconsin will discuss her paper "In Evil or
Reckless Hands: The Secret History of Crime, Race and Science in Skinner v. Oklahoma." The
paper will be precirculated, so please let us know if you
would
like a copy.
Location: The
Faculty Conference
Center at the George Washington University Law School (on the 5th floor
of the
Burns Law Library), at noon on Friday, February 10. The main
entrance to the
law school is at 20th and H Streets, NW. Lunch will be provided, so
please RSVP
to icsgw@law.gwu.edu
as soon as
possible.
This
colloquium is co-sponsored by the George Washington University Law
School
works-in-progress
committee.
March
2006
Friday,
March 17, noon
Colloquium:
Professor David Barron of the Harvard Law School will present a paper on the power of local
officials
to make independent interpretations of state or federal constitutional
law
entitled "Why (and When) Cities Have a Stake in Enforcing the
Constitution." His paper focuses on the conflict between the Mayor of
San
Francisco and state officials in California over the question of
same-sex
marriage. The paper will be precirculated, so please let us know if you
would
like a copy.
Location: The
Faculty Conference
Center at the George Washington University Law School (on the 5th floor
of the
Burns Law Library), at noon on Friday, March 17. The main
entrance to the
law school is at 20th and H Streets, NW. Lunch will be provided, so
please RSVP
to icsgw@law.gwu.edu
as soon as
possible.
This
colloquium is co-sponsored by the George Washington University Law
School
works-in-progress
committee.
Thursday,
March 23, 4:00 p.m.
Panel
discussion: "The Confrontation Clause vs. Effective Domestic Violence Prosecution?
A
Panel Discussion of the Pending Hammon/Davis Cases
in the Supreme Court"
The
Hammon/Davis cases (Hammon
v. Indiana and Davis v. Washington),
both involving domestic violence against women, have raised significant
issues
about the confrontation clause of the Sixth Amendment—and
there is
much
historical content to be found in the briefs on both sides. The Supreme
Court
is scheduled to hear oral arguments for these cases on March 20.
Panelists:
Timothy O'Toole,
Chief, Special Litigation Section, Public Defender Service of D.C.
(O'Toole is
author of the leading amicus brief supporting the
defendants/appellants); Mary
McCord, Deputy Chief, Sex Offense and Domestic Violence Unit,
U.S. Attorney's
Office (McCord assisted with the brief for the U.S. Solicitor General
and is
litigating two pending appeals in the District of Columbia on this
issue); Joan S. Meier,
Professor of Clinical Law and Director, Domestic Violence Legal
Empowerment and
Appeals Project, George Washington University Law School; moderated
by Stephen
A. Saltzburg, Professor of Law, George Washington University
Law School.
Location: The
George Washington
University Law School, Lerner 401, at 4:00 p.m. on Thursday, March 23.
The law
school is located at 20th and H Streets NW; Lerner 401 is more or less
directly
above the main entrance to the building on the 4th floor. Light
refreshments
will be served following the discussion.
This
event is co-sponsored by the Domestic Violence Legal Empowerment and
Appeals
Project, the George Washington University Law School, and the
Washington
Council of Lawyers.
Friday,
March 24, noon
Colloquium:
Professor Melissa
Schwartzberg of the political science department at George
Washington
University will present a paper entitled "Against Entrenchment." A
brief description is included below. Copies of her paper will be
precirculated;
please let us know if you would like to receive one. This event is
co-sponsored
by the American
Political Science Association (APSA).
Location: The
colloquium will be held
at the headquarters of the APSA, 1527 New Hampshire Ave, NW,
Washington, DC.
(The nearest Metro stop is Dupont Circle.) This is a brown-bag event,
though drinks
will be provided courtesy of the APSA. Please RSVP to icsgw@law.gwu.edu as soon as possible if
you plan to attend.
Here is
a brief preview of
the paper from Prof. Schwartzberg:
"Although
democrats have used
immutable, or 'entrenched,' law since ancient Athens, contemporary
constitutionalists should resist the adoption of unamendable laws. In
this
paper, I review four key types of entrenchment, from temporally limited
restrictions on change to robust but implicit forms of immutability. I
then
briefly present the logic that governed the use of entrenchment in
ancient
Athens, in Cromwell's Instrument of Government, and in the American
founding as
a means of highlighting the strategic and instrumental purposes to
which legislators
have put entrenchment. Entrenchment should not be used even as a means
of
protecting rights or foundational commitments (e.g., to human dignity);
rather
than excluding the possibility of change, I suggest, entrenchment
shifts the
locus of amendment away from legislatures and toward courts. In
conclusion, I
outline the broader democratic implications of the use of entrenchment,
and
defend an approach to constitutionalism that embraces the capacity to
learn
through ongoing public deliberation."
April 2006
Friday,
April 14, noon
Colloquium: Professor
Heather Gerken
of the Harvard Law School will present a paper entitled "Dissenting by
Deciding." Her paper examines complex questions of whether certain
kinds of official decisions — say, by juries, school boards,
or other
decision-making bodies — might be understood not just as
"action" but
as dissent from majoritarian norms. The paper will be precirculated, so
please let us know if you’d like a copy.
Location: The
Faculty Conference
Center at the George Washington University Law School (on the 5th floor
of the
Burns Law Library), at noon on Friday, April 14. The main
entrance to the
law school is at 20th and H Streets, NW. Lunch will be provided, so
please RSVP
to icsgw@law.gwu.edu
as soon as
possible.
This
colloquium is co-sponsored by the George Washington University Law
School
works-in-progress
committee.
June
2006
Summer
seminar: "War Powers
and the Constitution." Please
follow this link for more information.
September
2006
Sunday, September 3, 8:00-9:30 am
Panel:
"The
Constitution and the Civil War"
This
panel will explore the impact that secession,
surrender, Reconstruction and the post-Civil War Amendments had on the
American constitutional order. On some readings, the
constitution of 1868 merely perfected the constitution of 1787, as
Americans realized their constitutional aspiration to end
slavery. On other readings, the constitution of 1868 was an
entirely new constitutional order, with entirely new commitments to
equality or other values. We have assembled some of the
leading thinkers in law and political science to debate these issues.
Panelists: Sanford Levinson,
University of Texas-Austin (chair); Pamela Brandwein,
University of Texas-Dallas; James
R.
Stoner, Louisiana State University; Mark E. Brandon,
Vanderbilt Law School; Daniel
Hamilton, University of Chicago-Kent School of Law, and Mark
A. Graber, University of Maryland.
Location:
Annual
meeting of the American
Political Science
Association (Philadelphia, PA); conference
registration is required to attend this
session.
This
panel is sponsored by the Institute for Constitutional Studies.
October 2006
Thursday, October 5, 4:00-5:15
Meet the Author: USA Today Supreme
Court correspondent Joan
Biskupic discusses her recent book on Justice Sandra Day
O'Connor, Sandra Day
O'Connor: How the First Woman on the Supreme Court Became Its Most
Influential Justice.
Location: Faculty Conference Center (Burns
505), George Washington University Law
School, at 4:00 pm on Thursday, October 5. The
main
entrance to the
law school is at 20th and H Streets, NW.
Wednesday, October 18, 4:00-5:30
Workshop: Professor Barry Friedman of
the New York University Law School will present material from his
forthcoming book on
judicial review. A draft chapter — The Birth of
Judicial Review ("this Great Constitutional Question") — will be precirculated, so please let us
know in advance if you would like to attend.
Location: Faculty Library (Burns 506),
George Washington University Law
School, at 4:00 pm on Wednesday, October 18. The
main
entrance to the
law school is at 20th and H Streets, NW.
November 2006
Monday, November 6, 3:30-5:00
Author
Meets Critics: Supreme
Court
Justice Stephen Breyer
discusses his recent book, Active
Liberty: Interpreting Our Democratic Constitution, and
responds to comments by Joel
Grossman (Johns Hopkins University), Ira C. Lupu (George
Washington University), and Max
Stearns (University of Maryland School of Law). Moderated
by Frederick M. Lawrence (dean of the GW Law
School).
Location: Supreme
Court of the United States
(One 1st Street, NE), EAST Conference Room. Use the Maryland Avenue
entrance; the East Conference Room is on the first floor. We recommend
that attendees arrive early to leave sufficient time for security
measures at the Court building (metal detector and I.D. check).
Reservations are required, so please contact the Institute
if you plan to attend.
Wednesday,
November 15, noon-1:30
Colloquium: Professor William J. Stuntz of the Harvard Law School will present a paper entitled "Fighting Wars
and Fighting Crime." The paper will be precirculated, so please let us
know if
you would like a copy.
Location
(note change): The
Jacob Burns Moot Court Room, George Washington University Law School
(on the ground floor of the
Burns Law Library), at noon on Wednesday,
November 15. The main
entrance to the
law school is at 20th and H Streets, NW. Lunch will be provided, so
please RSVP
to icsgw@law.gwu.edu
as soon as
possible.
This
colloquium is co-sponsored by the George Washington University Law
School
works-in-progress
committee.
Friday,
November 17, noon-1:30
(rescheduled from November 10)
Colloquium:
Professor Jack Goldsmith of
the Harvard Law School will present a paper entitled "Sosa, Customary
International Law, and the Continuing Relevance of Erie."
The paper is available now, so please let us know if you
would
like a copy.
Location
(note change): The Great Room of the Burns Law Library at the George Washington
University Law School (on the first floor, next to the main elevator),
at noon on Friday, November 17. The main
entrance to the
law school is at 20th and H Streets, NW. Lunch will be provided, so
please RSVP
to icsgw@law.gwu.edu
as soon as
possible.
This
colloquium is co-sponsored by the George Washington University Law
School
works-in-progress
committee.
Thursday, January 25, 4:00-5:30
Workshop: Professor Anthony J. Bellia, Jr. of
the University of Notre Dame will present a paper entitled
"The Origins of Article III 'Arising Under' Jurisdiction." A copy of
the paper will be precirculated, so please let us
know in advance if you would like to attend.
Here
is an abstract of the paper provided by Prof. Bellia:
Article
III of the Constitution provides that the “judicial
Power”
of the United States extends to all cases “arising
under”
the Constitution, laws, and treaties of the United States. What the
phrase “arising under” imports in Article III has
long
confounded courts and scholars. This paper examines the historical
origins of Article III “arising under”
jurisdiction. The
Supreme Court has been mindful of historical understandings in
determining the scope of various heads of Article III jurisdiction;
accordingly, the analysis that this paper presents is of both
historical and doctrinal interest. The paper proceeds in four stages.
First, it describes jurisdictional principles of English law that
provide necessary context for understanding early political and
judicial arguments about the meaning of “arising
under.”
Second, it explains how participants in the framing of Article III and
in debates over its ratification described “arising
under”
jurisdiction. Third, it explains the import that early American courts,
invoking English jurisdictional principles, gave to Article III
“arising under” jurisdiction. In particular, this
paper
explains, in its proper historical context, the meaning of the landmark
1824 case Osborn v. United States, in which Chief Justice John Marshall
described a case as “arising under” federal law if
a
federal law “forms an ingredient of the original
cause.”
Finally, the paper identifies certain implications of this history for
our understandings of Article III “arising under”
jurisdiction today.
Location: Faculty Library (Burns 506), George Washington University Law School,
at 4:00 pm on Thursday, January 25. The main entrance to the
law school is at 20th and H Streets, NW.
Tuesday,
January 30, noon
Colloquium:
Professor Michael I.
Meyerson
of the University of Baltimore School of Law (and a visiting professor
of law at George Washington University) will present a paper
entitled "Liberty's Blueprint: How Madison and Hamilton Wrote the Federalist,
Defined the Constitution, and Made Democracy Safe for the World." The
paper will be precirculated, so please let us know if you would like a
copy.
Location: The Faculty Conference Center at the George Washington University Law
School (on the 5th floor of the Burns Law Library), at noon on Tuesday,
January 30. The main entrance to the law school is at 20th and
H
Streets, NW. Lunch will be provided, so please RSVP to icsgw@law.gwu.edu
in advance.
This
colloquium is co-sponsored by the George Washington University Law
School works-in-progress committee.
February 2007
Starting
February
7,
ICS will offer a non-credit Graduate
Seminar on "Judicial Biography," led by Professor Melvin
I. Urofsky (Virginia Commonwealth University). Please
follow this link for more information.
March 2007
Wednesday,
March 14, noon (revised date)
Colloquium:
Professor Martha Ertman of
the University of Utah law school (and visiting professor of law at
George Washington University) will present a paper on
"The Story of Reynolds
v. U.S.: Federal 'Hell Hounds' Punishing Mormon
Treason" (a chapter from the forthcoming book, Family Law Stories).
The paper will be
precirculated, so please let us know if you would like a copy.
Location: Student Conference Center, Lisner
Hall (second floor), George Washington University Law School. Lunch
will be provided, so
please RSVP to icsgw@law.gwu.edu
in advance.
This
colloquium is co-sponsored by the George Washington University Law
School works-in-progress
committee.
Thursday,
March 29, 3:15
Author
Meets Critics:
Professor William M.
Wiecek (Congdon Professor of Law and Professor of History at Syracuse
University) will discuss his new volume in the Oliver Wendell
Holmes
Devise History of the Supreme Court,The
Birth of the Modern Constitution: The United States Supreme Court,
1941-1953 (Cambridge
University Press, 2006). The author will also respond to comments by
Melvin Urofsky (Virginia Commonwealth University), Mark Graber
(University of Maryland School of Law), and others.
Location: University of Maryland School of
Law, 500 West Baltimore Street, Baltimore, MD.
|